Please log in this format (please don't change this example just copy and paste it]: -------- [title of the talk] //see schedule in the other tab [nick of the observer angle] -------- [timestamp system time hh:mm] herald introduces the speaker and talk [timestamp system time hh:mm] speaker starts the talk [timestamp system time hh:mm] [$Suggestion for Improvement] ... [timestamp system time hh:mm] talk ends --> [Conclusion here] _____________________________________________________ -------- Lightning Talks Day 4 Billi -------- [11:30] herald stands on the stage but the sound is missing. they were aware of it [11:31] herald explains the lightning talk system [11:34] first lightning talk starts. herald is shown for a short time instead of speaker [11:39] first lightning talk ends [11:40] second lightning talk starts [11:44] second lightning talk ends [11:45] third lightning talk starts [11:50] third lightning talk ends [11:51] fourth lightning talk starts [11:53] fourth lightning talk ends [11:53] fifth lightning talk ends [11:54] the picture hang for a second [11:55] stream hang for a second [11:56] stream hang for a second [11:57] stream hang for a second [11:57] fifth lightning talk ends [11:57] sixth lightning talk starts [12:03] sixth lightning talk ends [12:03] seventh lightning talk starts [12:08] seventh lightning talk ends [12:08] eighth lightning talk starts [12:10] sound was missing for a few seconds [12:11] sound was missing for a few seconds [12:13] eighth lightning talk ends [12:13] ninth lightning talk starts [12:18] ninth lightning talk ends [12:18] sound was missing for a few seconds [12:19] tenth lightning talk starts [12:21] room camera is shown without a reason [12:23] room camera is shown without a reason [12:23] tenth lightning talk ends [12:24] eleventh lightning talk starts [12:29] eleventh lightning talk ends [12:30] start of 15 minute break [12:45] end of break [12:46] twelfth lightning talk starts [12:50] twelfth lightning talk ends [12:50] thirteenth lightning talk starts [12:55] thirteenth lightning talk ends [12:56] fourteenth lightning talk starts [13:01] fourteenth lightning talk ends [13:01] fifteenth lightning talk starts [13:06] fifteenth lightning talk ends [13:07] sixteenth lightning talk starts [13:09] switch to full speaker because cam got hit. slides could have been better [13:11] sixteenth lightning talk ends [13:11] seventeenth lightning talk starts [13:16] seventeenth lightning talk ends [13:17] eighteenth lightning talk starts [13:22] sound was missing two times for a second [13:22] eighteenth lightning talk ends [13:22] nineteenth lightning talk starts [13:27] nineteenth lightning talk ends [13:27] twentieth lightning talk starts [13:33] twentieth lightning talk ends [13:34] lightning talks session ends -------- Briar eshon -------- [13:44] cut to middle of herald introducing the speaker and talk, wish stream started a little sooner [13:46] nice cut to speaker smiling [13:46] speaker starts the talk [13:47] speaker is a walker and pacer so good cut to full body widescreen [13:48] nice cuts back and forth from SBS to full body because he moves so much [13:48] full body view heavy on the right side of the screen rather than center [13:49] "we skill ppl based on metadata" might more impactful full slide rather than watchin the speaker drink his water [13:50] nice to see full body camera has the hang of the speaker's habitual walk box and doesn't move [13:51] he is so hard fo follow with the camera this must be hard for the camera person [13:52] this is a complex slide make it full screen please [13:53] maybe full slide would be better at first so they have more impact [13:54] can see lots of heads and someone's profile walking across the room but nice to see the full stage [13:56] wish SBS speaker view was lower so there's less head space [13:59] nice pan so camera is not chasing the speaker like in SBS [13:59] wish SBS was lower so there's less head space [14:01] camera doesn't move with speaker as he goes to the right of the frame but it works fine since he just walked the stage/whole frame [14:03] nice to see speaker pointing at the slide in SBS [14:06] the SBS camera following is kind of funny [14:06] full room is nice for this decentralize all the things slide as they clap! [14:08] not sure if this simple app store slide is necessary for so long in SBS [14:09] are we ever going to get a closer up view of this dude? :\ [14:09] talk ends [14:09] nice view of herald...oops too long saw him checking his watch as Q was being asked [14:10] too much space above speaker head, could have more lower body? [14:12] nice following of speaker as he walks [14:14] one moment of janky panning while following speaker [14:15] nice to catch the end of the speaker bowing [14:16] herald suddenly cut off mid-sentence wish there could have been an audio fade --> Overall great job following a speaker who loves to pace and the excitement of the room for Briar came through during that 2nd full room cut and later during QandA. SBS for too long can be frustrating on a small screen so every time mixer cut to full screen speaker view that felt like a relief. In the middle some of the slides could have been full screen to start more often before cutting to SBS. Also wish Herald intro had been captured from the start and more smoothly closed out. _____________________________________________________ -------- Privacy Shield eshon -------- [14:27] herald introduces french translation in french [14:27] herald introduces the speaker by pointing off screen [14:27] no speaker in view as speaker talks and reacts to herald in conversation [14:29] speaker is speaking a lot but haven't seen him yet at all [14:29] herald and speaker conversing with both on screen now [14:30] nice segueway from herald bowing to speaker view [14:30] speaker + podium combo are a little off center [14:30] interesting zoom out [14:30] nice PIP works well with this slide [14:33] PIP covered up the smiley face on the slide for a second [14:34] nice full slide since slide was complicated [14:35] blank screen for 1 second [14:35] cut to SBS speaker is not centered - slowing centering over the next couple seconds [14:36] really nice tight framing of speaker in this SBS view now [14:37] can't see one section of the slide that well (User Activity Possible Queries form)... then you made it full screen, better [14:38] SBS works great here since slides are easier to read/simple [14:39] full slides to SBS to full speaker was nice [14:41] full speaker could lead to some view closer in to the speaker? [14:43] glad to see full screen speaker after SBS with slides of 2 buildings [14:44] PIP works well here but speaker could be centered a little more [14:45] nice cut to room clapping [14:46] might be nice to have speaker close up soon... [14:47] here it is [14:48] SBS makes sense - lots of bullet points [14:51] SBS cut to full screen email response a little abrupt but full screen was easier to read [14:52] glad this text heavy slide is full screen [14:53] glad this low contrast sankey arrow slide is full screen [14:55] this slide is hard to read, glad its full screen [14:58] glad these highlighted text slides are full screen [14:59] SBS to full screen slide was nice more complex flow chart stuff, this speaker loves lots of arrows [15:02] what a cute pig where did that go [15:02] speaker is over time so rushing so no time for QandA [15:03] nice to keep explanation by herald of why --> Overall SBS was perfect for most of the speaker's slides, nice centering during SBS for the most part, nice PIP usage 2 on those slides. once the full room view was a weak clap but other times worked well. _____________________________________________________ –––––––– 34C3 Infrastructure Review sivizius –––––––– [15:12] online, good tracking of and view on herald. [15:15] introduction of talk, a bit blurred, but could be stream. [15:15] talk starts. [15:16] more slides, use side-by-side or picture-in-picture. camera on the two speakers could be a bit lower. [15:20] show slides early. everyone laughts, but you cannot understand, if you see the stream. [15:21] better switch to slides before adjusting camera view and then switch back. [15:24] bad camera view for picture-in-picture. [15:28] camera on herald, while speakers speaking. [15:30] switch to speakers earlier while Q&A. [15:32] just have speakers in fullscreen, the slides are annoying, because Q&A is quite obvious here. [15:36] looks good. [15:40] font is big enough for side-by-side/there is place for picture-in-picture, but slides in fullscreen are good enough. [15:42] no use of slides. [15:44] tracking of speaker could be better. a wee bit too much space around speaker, better zoom in a bit. [15:50] herald looks a wee bit blurry. he was too early anyway ^^ [15:50] white font on white background. m( [15:53] better use picture-in-picture or side-by-side instead of switching between sllides and speaker often. [15:57] good tracking of herald. [16:03] black frame in slides? [16:06] tracking of herald looks good. [16:06] end of talk and offline. –––––––– use more slide-by-slide and picture-in-picture, but this was really good. it was not an usual talk. –––––––– -------- Tracking Transience Nakaner (all four talks simultaneously) ------- 16:44 The cameraman who follows the speaker does a great work. 16:58 please tilt up and zoom out a bit if the speaker regularly points upwards