Please log in this format: -------- Opening JK -------- 11:00 - Herald opens the talk 11:03 - Speaker 11:28 - end Suggestion for Improvement: CloseUp-Cam too dark Symbols and Numbers too long in full view Too much headroom when 2 person -------- Dude, you broke the Future JK -------- 11:30 - Herald opens the talk 11:32 - Speaker 12:30 - end Good camera and mixer work! Sometimes too much headroom -------- Ladeinfrastruktur ... JKO -------- 12:45 - Herald opens the talk 12:46 - Speaker 12:47 - Soundaussetzer | lokales Problem Laptop? 12:49 - Schwarze, leere Slides 12:57 - Falsche cam 13:12 - Längerer Freeze | lokales Problem Laptop? 13:26 - Questions? 13:38 - end Feedback: Camera choice could be improved, sometimes wrong/empty camera selected Great work with moving slides/videos! 34c3 watermark top-left sometimes interferes with on screen terminal lines ------- Gamified Control JKO ------- 14:00 - Herald opens the talk 14:01 - Speaker 14:04 - Wrong cut 14:07 - Camera too wide, unstable picture, herald/speaker walking/sliding in/out of frame 14:10 - Video not fullscreen 14:39 - Q/A -> not streamed on purpose Feedback: Audio cuts often times slightly to late (room audio mid-applause for example) Adding PIP Slides-Speaker after switching to slides fullscreen feels disrupting. Especially if the pip has to be disabled soon after because it's getting in the way of text. ------- How risky is the software you use? incase ------- 15:12 Herald gets on stage (game, cover tech problems) 15:14 still tech problems (which?) 15:15 real intro starts. It's visible that there is a first slide on. Should show it. 15:16 audience partially visible 15:16 Showing slide only, not speaker. 15:18: Speaker clearly speaking about points on the slide, which is hidden. 15:20 Speaker walks out of frame because speaker desk wasn't sufficiently in frame 15:21 Showing a title only slide very long 15:22 showing illegible slide for very long without the speaker referring to it. 15:25 Again: Audience in view - As for the previous instance, I doubt anyone was identifiable. Still shouldn't happen 15:37 Should have shown the slide earlier while the speaker clearly spoke about what it showed. 15:50 Showed a title slide for very long, then switched to speaker exactly when the actual slide would have shown. 16:00 Slide shown too short to be comprehensible 16:08 Q&A starts 16:13: Total showing audience including some faces! 16:14 Q&A ended Feedback: * Make use of image composition (at all) - leads to less cuts with a much smoother viewing experience on the stream. * Don't show the audience, even in wide totals. * On average, most stream users (at least at the conference I usually do video - DebConf) are more interested in the slides than the speaker. * Show slides for longer when they are new. Give viewers the time to comprehend them. To the speakers: * At 15:42 (computability perspective), the slide was very hard to read, similarly the slide shortly after (Bayesian perspective 1/3) should also have used a slightly larger font - in general: Pretty thin-lined fonts used especially in graphs, which isn't well readable, particularly on stream/recording) ------- Die Lauschprogramme der Geheimdienste ------- 16:23 Video of herald starts, no audio 16:24 audio starts, stops again, then back to break slide 16:25 back to herald, with audio. some switches between herald video and title slide 16:30 real intro starts, audience shown twice for a few seconds 16:31 no audio, then wrong microphone, then audio works starting at 16:32 (informed VOC) 16:34 close-up Ströbele slightly out of focus, Kurz cut in half 16:36 better close-up Ströbele 16:39 correction of close-up Ströbele after a few seconds, thanks :) 16:45 from time to time, cut to full screen slide showing square sketches from the NSAUA (not directly relevant to currently said words), could be used as picture in picture instead 17:06 cuts to slide pictures seem unnecessary 17:07 audience shot with many people visible from behind 17:08 begin Q&A 17:21 too much headspace for close-up 17:23 another audience shot 17:26 end of talk, another audience shot 17:26 multiple backs of heads visible in herald shot 17:27 end of stream Overall feedback: * good cuts between both speakers and single speaker * audience totals not necessary when audience is applauding * cuts to "slides" seemed unnecessary, could be used as picture in picture -------- Quality Land _Lucy_ -------- 18:31 Herald runs out of Frame 18:31 too much audience in frame 18:33 audience shot with too many people visible from behind 18:34 irritating: camera of close-up zooms in and out 18:36 too much audience in a shot of the whole stage 18:37 video away for short, not relevant 18:35 camera of close up 'shivering' 18:38 video away for a half second 18:39 close-up too dark 18:39 audience shot again 18:40 video away for short, not relevant 18:41 mini zoom in of the closeup camera, irritating 18:41 video away for some millisecs 18:42 too much audience in a shot of the Beamer(middle screen) 18:45 half of the frame is the Speakers Desk, closeup or whole stage please 18:48 too much audience again, shot is too wide 18:52 video away for very short 18:52 heads on the bottom 18:52 do not show so much of the beamer if there is just their feet moving in frame 18:54 correction of what is visible on the beamer in frame 18:55 too much audience and also the right screen visible 18:56 audience on the bottom of frame 18:57 audience and right screen(half of) visible 18:59 closeup camera 'shivering' but speaker is more centered now than he was first sitting there 19:00 both people on stage on the far ends of the frame is not beautiful 19:01 video away for a picture 19:01 camera shivering again, please don't touch it if you have the right setting for the closeup, and don't move your feet so much, I know that is hard, but you can see every small movement :) 19:03 video away for one pic 19:04 Bassist cut on the right side of the frame 19:07 too much audience, right screen is visible 19:08 closeup of both and speaker alone better than before :) 19:09 bad sound of the mic of singer, especially if he's too close to mic 19:10 other mic also --> maybe interferences with the guitar? its better when hes not playing 19:12 audience and right screen again 19:13 heads on the bottom, speakers on the far ends of the frame 19:14 audience and right screen again, if you want the whole stage in a shot, please don't include the side screens and not the audience on the whole bottom third of the screen 19:16 Stream is away (all 4 streams at the same time) 19:17 Stream restarted in vlc 19:18 closeup camera shivering,the nearer closeup is better 19:21 speaker is too close to the side end of the frame 19:24 too much audience, but better than before 19:24 heads on the bottom, speaker too close to the left end of frame 19:26 the stage camera showed too much of the speakers desk 19:29 zoom out okay but not necessary 19:30 audience visible again, herald is visible on the side, screen too wide 19:32 audience visible 19:32 stream ended -------- Der PC-Wahl-Hack neumantm -------- 19:46 - Herald 19:47 Head room to large 19:47 Zooming live on stream 19:48 Speakrers discussing before talk with live audio, then break again. 19:54 Herald opens the talk a second time 19:54 Herald talking out of the frame 19:55 - Speakers starting to talk 19:55 Headspace 19:55 Right speaker cut 19:58 Speaker talking out of the frame 19:58 Speakers bottem right of Slides would have been nice 20:00 Speaker almost out of frame 20:01 Headspace 20:04 Headspace 20:05 Sound not playing for < 2s 20:12 Speakers cut in half 20:13 Other speakers stepping in and out of frame 20:14 Sound of latop only through microphones ! 20:16 Camera in B covering slides in A 20:18 Sound out again for < 2s 20:22 Second speaker cut in half 20:24 Speaker out of frame 20:26 Speakers cut in half 20:27 Headspace 20:33 Speaker not on camera 20:34 Speaker cut in half 20:35 Sound glitch again 20:36 Herald weirdly in shot on bottom right 20:40 sound glitch again 20:41 Speaker not in shot 20:41 Speaker cut in half 20:43 Speaker cut in half 20:45 End of talk 20:46 Q/A 20:46 Herald not heared in stream for a short time 20:49 END 20:49 Speaker audio stil live.l 20:49 Infobeamer on stream 20:56 Stream gone completely 21:08 Stream gone completely again -------- Die Sprache der Überwacher neumantm -------- 21:16 STREAM OFFLINE 21:17 Stream ist da 21:17 Audio missing for < 5s 21:17 Headspace way too much 21:18 Sound glitch < 2s 21:19 Sound not in Stream 21:20 Headspace still way too much (the camera that is zoomed out more) 21:21 Sound glitch < 5s 21:22 A lot of empty space in multiple directions 21:24 Static Noise (i think not only in Stream?) 21:25 Lag 21:25 Sound Glitch < 2s 21:27 A lot of space around speakers 21:28 Sound glitch < 10s 21:30 A lot of space around speakers on both cams 21:33 Image dark 21:43 Brighness changing(is this the camera or stage light?) 21:46 Speaker, that is currently speaking is mostly behind desk. Camera never on desk and that speaker only, always on all three speakers. 21:48 End of Talk 21:48 Some speech live on stream. From video mixer?! 21:48 END -------- Die fabelhafte Welt des Mobilebanking Michos -------- 21:58 Stream first few seconds without audio 22:00 Talk starts 22:03 Sound glitch ~5s 22:05 Nice use of super source 22:09 Fast switching between full-screen slides and PIP 22:10 Speaker pretty small in super source (IMO) 22:14 <1s video glitch (black) 22:20 New slide too small 22:21 Some fast cuts in addition to fast content of app demo 22:24 new slides only in super source 22:26 End of Talk 22:31 END -------- DPRK Consumer Technology Michos -------- 22:46 Herald comes on screen mid-sentence 22:46 Too much headroom, cut right under knee 22:47 Audio drop out 22:48 both speakers in frame, only one talking for long 22:50 supersource with wrong framing of speaker, corrected on-stream 22:52 speaker looking out of frame 23:00 speaker cut at ellbow 23:01 both speakers on screen with only one speaking and the non-speaking one in the dark for very long. 23:01 Wrong speaker in super-source 23:04 text-heavy slide in super source not readable 23:17 End of Talk 23:17 many faces on stream 23:17 infobeamer on stream, herald cut off during orga annoucements 23:17 stream ends -------- KRACKing WPA2 by Forcing - Nonce Reuse flennic -------- 23:28 start: audio but no video (general problem, mixer gets no notification) 23:28 mix: speaker shown while herald is talking 23:31 mix: good timing on showing slides, but picture-inpicture (ptp) overlaps text on slides (longer than 5s) 23:35 mix: Showing and switching between slides/speaker/ptp is great :) 23:36 cam: focus seems to be on the speakers desk, not on the speaker himself 23:39 mix: perfect timing for showing slides in full screen 23:42 mix: you're good, why not trying side-by-side (sbs)? [: 23:47 cam: roomlight or aperture is changing while on fullscreen 23:57 the view at the speaker could be closer from time to time 00:03 really good so far! 00:08 audio seems to clip (skipping milliseconds) 00:14 slide about the state machine was shown a little bit short (but there seemed to be a problem with the slides, so maybe it was that?) 00:20 switch to herald/overview was a little bit late, but no problem :) 00:31 In general: Very well done!