Please log in this format: -------- Lobby-Schlacht um die ePrivacy-Verordnung [JK -------- ??- Herald opens the talk 12:13 - Jumped in observing 12:30 - end CloseUp cam too light (1EV down) Good camera frame! --------- End-to-End formal ISA --------- 12:49 jump in the stream 13:14 end slides 13:14 Q&A 13:17 end Q&A already started low Sound someone jumped on the camera stage good jump between slide and person (on point) good choice to show the speaker on the slide (12:55 riscv-formal) more jumping on the camera stage camera to far from the speaker, he didn't move or something, also the space above his head is way to much jump to the speaker, he was talking not about the slide close up the speaker, he doesn't move and not show the slide don't show the audience, when the light is on! --------- The Work of Art in the Age of Digital Assassination --------- 13:32: start of the talk 13:43: end of the talk 13:43: Q&A 13:48: Q&A end should not only show the slide stream lags stream offline when the camera is adjusting, show slides or other camera to much space on the right mic of the herald is not on the record when they talk, don't show the next upcoming slide don't show somethingfrom the grabber --------- WTFrance --------- 14:16 Herald open the talk 14:17 talk starts 14:40 talk end 14:40 Q&A starts 1447: Q&A end jumping camera she should be introduced how to position the microphone other speaker had no sound don't use camera who film both in the right corner close up to the person who speak, the other is not relevant the speaker has no sound on the record don't use the wide camera perspective in the right corner, especially when the left half is completly empty ---------- Science is broken VBen --------- 14:57 herarld appers to low volume 14:58 heradl cut in half 14:59 speaker appers but herald talks 15:00 herald volume is ok now herald an speaker not in center 15:00 Talk starts Starts too much audience 15:02 Speaker not in center Speaker is breathing to microphone 15:03 speakers gestres outside of his "window" 15:04 too much emty space on lft side of speaker 15:05 Speaker sometimes splitted 15:07 steps in camera pan and tilt 15:08 bag besides the speaker desk does not look good, but good full view 15:09 good camera perspective 15:11 Speaker too small 15:13 cut audience heads visible 15:17 ther sould be one pip mode specially for 4:3 slides to get rid of the black bars on the left and right to get more sapce for a picture in picture 15:20 too much space left of spaker 15:21 better camera picture but stacked 34C3 logo 15:23 too much audience 15:24 speaker to small to see 15:27 talk ended unexpected Q&A starts, Herald appears 15:27 too much audience during Q&A 15:28 cut speaker in split view, then cut slides in "speaker window" 15:29 sildes cut the arm of the speaker 15:30 Herald not in picture while talking 15:31 Audience visible 15:31 Stream stops while herald is talking -------- Algorithmic Science VBen ------- No time between the talks are delaying the second talk General: a 4:3 sliede split mode should be available perhaps the stage manager should mention the best position for the co speaker while tey are not speaking to prvent them form appering cut in the stream 15:33 Talk starts unexpectet with slides Hear the speakers getting their mics 15:35 Herald only on edge of picture, camera not following afterwards 15:35 cut speakers, strange camera movement 15:35 speaker to low at the beginning, cut co speaker at the edge 15:38 Bad camera picture(cut speaker, only co speaker visible) 15:40 while switching the sources the wrong camera picture was at first chosen 15:41 little bit too much head room above the speaker 15:43 camera panned sideways an a cut arm of the co speaker appears 15:44 non optimal microphone position speaker is breathing into the mic 15:48 good picture of all three speakers while laughing 15:49 camer picture shaking a little bit 15:51 cut co speaker 15:52 good fast reaction on cut tetx on slide du to picture in picture 16:00 talk ended herald appers 16:00 to much audioence 16:00 Q&A Starts Durning a question the speakers hould be shown instead of the overvirew 16:02 one hall microphone not working 16:03 Speakers not visible during answering a question 16:05 has to cut off the Q&A session 16:05 speakers are getting rid of their microphones, but the mics were not muted 16:05 stream ended ---------- 1-day exploit development for Cisco IOS Benjojo ---------- 16:28 - Talk Starts 16:36 - View of presenter is quite unzoomed, some head space could be reduced? 16:38 - PIP blocked view of slides ( was reacted to quickly though! ) 16:51 - Nice angle for the split view, makes it look like the presenter is actively looking at the slides 16:54 - Mixer is a big fan of PIP view, Sometimes a bit too much since it ends up blocking the slides at times, and by the time its disabled, the view of the side is onlz up for a second or so 17:08 - Nice switch away while presenter having window manager issues 17:11 - QA begins 17:11 - Odd delay feedback on Microphone 1 (sounds strange) 17:14 - Talk ends, stream is blanked. --------- iOS kernel exploitation archaeology Nakaner --------- 18:31 Stream starts with the slides. The stream should start with a view on the stage. 18:32 introduction by herald should be shown and not only available on audio 18:33 If you do side by side, please film the speaker (there is no co-speaker) close up. 18:40 The slide contains a lot of small text (a screenshot). Please show it fullscreen, not side-by-side. 18:41 Thank you for switching to slides fullscreen (but too late). 18:41 switch back to side-by-side during the next slide but not using the chance to zoom more on the speaker. 18:42 Good reaction on a slide with lots of source code 18:44 Slides with source code should be fullscreen. 18:44 thank you for switching to fullscreen while speaker switches through his slides 18:45 PIP, great, this slide has space in the lower right corner but you should not use the same camera as for side by side because the speaker is currently to far away from centre. 18:46 Slide "Debugging setup" has text in lower right corner. If you do PIP, you have to react quickly. 18:48 PIP is good here 18:51 (general note) Showing slides a lot is a good idea in this talk. 18:52 Thank you for zooming nearer with the camera to the speaker. 19:00 Please show this long source code listing which has a low constrast between the text and the background in fullscreen and stay in fullscreen for a moment. 19:05 Winkekatze (on the left side) cut in side by side view 19:07 speaker cut a little bit on the right side from time to time 19:09 slide contains source code (small font size), fullscreen please 19:12 see above 19:14 slide fullscreen +1 19:16 stream stopped but pressing play button helped 19:19 end of talk, +1 for swithing to view on speaker 19:19 please show almost the whole stage in order that the herald is visible, too 19:19 view of herald contains a half chair on the left side 19:21 herald only patially in image 19:21 please avoid unnecessary panning while being live with this camera. You don't have to keep the eyes of the speaker at the same pixels of the image 19:22 unnecessary small pan movements (speaker view) 19:23 preemptitive swithing to herald is bad but I think you tried your best. 19:25 keep the image of the herald instead of streaming a speaker drinking water 19:25 moment when you stopped the stream is well chosen and makes it possible to find a good moment for cutting. -------- Watching the changing Earth sedrubal -------- 19:44 - Herald opens the talk 19:45 - speaker begins 19:45 - speaker mic was muted (after 1 phrase it worked) 19:46 - Slide title collides with 34C3 logo (top right corner) 19:47 - side by side is ok 19:50 - Cam1 could/should zoom in (too much headroom) 19:52 - Cam1 is not centered on speaker 19:52 - mixer could change to slides fullscreen 19:54 - mixer should change view (to e.g. fullscreen) 19:55 - Cam1 should center to speaker 19:57 - many formulars on slides (side by side is ok) 19:59 - is there a cam2? 20:00 - PIP was ok here 20:01 - small text on slide "Global Gravity Field: data access" -> put slides in fullscreen! 20:02 - slides shown quite (/too) long (read slides (only) twice) 20:04 - slides in fullscreen was better during animations IMHO 20:05 - no more information on slides -> put cam1/2 in fullscreen 20:06 - small text on slide "Results: Combination of Methods" -> put slides in fullscreen 20:07 - cam1 still not centered on speaker and zoomed in 20:08 - Speaker gets confused with slides (is wondering why there is no live demo -> "live demo doea not work" -> click click click -> speaker continues 20:09 - Small text on slide -> slides to fullscreen! 20:10 - see above 20:10 - again slides are messed up because of missing live demo 20:12 - text on image in slides 20:13 - don't show audience in cam3 20:13 - Q&A begins 20:14 - speaker in fullscreen is a good choice 20:15 - cam2 follows herald (very good) 20:16 - cam2 does not follow herald 20:16 - Q&A and talk ended 20:16 - stream continues showing the herald announcements for next talk 20:17 - pause video starts too late, one can hear the next camera angels! 20:17 - end -------- Low Cost Non-Invasive Biomedical Imaging sedrubal -------- 20:26 - pause video stopps suddenly and infobeamer is shown 20:27 - Herald begins with crowd control (defrag) 20:27 - cam2 (?) is shown and audience is shown!!! 20:28 - cam2 zooms in but it is waving to left and right (even if herald does not move much) 20:29 - Herald introduces into talk 20:29 - cam2 is following herald quite good 20:30 - good switch to cam1 20:30 - speaker was too quiet for some seconds 20:30 - pip overlaps image on slide, 34c3 logo overlaps headline 20:31 - cam1 has a bit too much headroom 20:32 - pip looks good, because speaker looks on slides 20:32 - slides fullscreen is right choice 20:34 - text on slide "Biomedical Imaging Overview" is a bit small (side by side makes it even smaller, but it is ok) 20:35 - speaker clicks through slides too fast 20:37 - 34C3 logo overlaps diagram legend -> side by side view solves the problem 20:39 - side by side with cam2 makes video more vivid (+1) 20:39 - images on slides overlap image titles (speaker fail) 20:41 - pip overlaps image (reacted 1 second before slide changes) 20:41 - 34C3 Logo overlaps image legend 20:43 - pip is nice here 20:44 - speaker skips slide 20:48 - speaker is surprised about er own slides 20:48 - slides contains light gray text color on white background 20:49 - text is too small on slide "Where to Next for openEIT?" -> side by side makes it too small 20:51 - side by side makes images with fine structures on slides too small 20:52 - slides flicker (sometimes black) for 2 seconds 20:55 - pip overlaps text (mixer reacted too slow) 20:55 - speaker finished & Herald starts Q&A 20:56 - cam2 follows herald quite well 20:56 - speaker sound has an echo and is too quiet for 5 seconds 20:57 - cam1 has too much headroom, can zoom in 21:02 - herald is over time, because stage manager does not give a sign 21:02 - there is an echo in speakers voice 21:03 - Q&A and talk ends 21:03 - speaker is not muted and is screaming into mic 21:04 - infobeamer is shown, no sound (I'm missing the pause music) 21:04 - end 21:05 - where is the pause video??? Or at least any music? 21:06 - pause video starts -------- Relativitätstheorie für blutige Anfänger sedrubal -------- 21:14 - Stream starts immediately with Heralds introduction 21:15 - Herald is quite excited, you're hearing the speaker breathing 21:15 - speaker starts 21:16 - speaker is walking up and down, cam1? is following very good 21:16 - cam3 is show, audience is shown from back (cam1/2 is better) 21:18 - speaker is walking out the image of cam1? 21:18 - cam2 is ok, too 21:20 - audience heads are shown, but it could/should zoom in! 21:21 - cam2 is sleeping and speakers is about to walk out the image -> mixer switches to cam1 21:23 - cam2 headroom is too large (all the time) and audience is shown -> just zoom in 21:24 - switch to cam1, speaker starts running -> speaker runs out of image 21:26 - cam2 is standing still, speaker is about to walk out of image -> mixer switches to cam1 21:28 - speaker points out of image of cam2 21:29 - cam2 zoomed in in the meantime and is ok now 21:33 - cam1 too much headroom (ok if speaker waves with his hands, you need this space) 21:34 - speaker is too far on the right end of the image on cam2 21:35 - cam2 too much headroom 21:36 - cam2 stands still and speaker walks out of image!!! 21:36 - mixer switches to cam3 -> audience is shown!!! 21:38 - cam2 stands still and speaker walks backward out of the image 21:38 - -||- 21:40 - -||- (even if you could see that speaker will run out of the image) 21:43 - cam2 too much headroom 21:44 - herold stops the talk but allows one Q&A question 21:46 - end 21:46 - pause video is only 1 second too late (very good) ------------ Catch me if you can: Internet Activism in Saudi Arabia Noujoum ------------ 22:00 -- Stream starts immediately with Heralds introduction 22:02 -- speaker starts 22:02 -- little popping in the sound of the speaker 22:06 -- speaker is not visible but a sheet that with two lines and not in focus of the talk at that moment 22:10 -- very long time without the speaker visible 22:10 -- speaker now visible again 22:12 -- popping in the audio is getting worse 22:17 -- another speaker enters the stage 22:17 -- sound of the second speaker is about 30 seconds too late, start of it is cut off 22:17 -- at the start people were cut of a little because of movement, using a zoomed out view would have been better 22:18 -- the other speaker leaves the stage; cut to the main speaker but the cam was not ready and stil did some panning and focus; not great, not super terrible 22:21 -- pip is used now again, could have been done a minute or two earlier, so the speaker would be visible 22:22 -- cut to the video in the slides feels a little late 22:22 -- adjustment of the laptop volume has some very loud unpleasent sound to it 22:24 -- winkekatze is cut in half panning a little to the left would solve it perfectly 22:25 -- cut to the video is much better now 22:26 -- noticebly and suddently reduction in the volume of the video 22:30 -- talk ends about 30 seconds late 22:30 -- q/a is omitted because of a lack of time 22:30 -- the herold is quite late in the video 22:31 -- someone stands up and flashes a face, not cool! 22:31 -- swith to the break is done and cuts the herolds words in the middle, maybe because no camera felt "safe" anymore ---------- Doping your Fitbit jiska, DanielAW ---------- 22:44 -- the Herold starts the introduction 22:46 -- the speakers start their talk 22:47 -- the voice dropped significantly in volume, feels quite quiet now, but you can stil understand everything 22:51 -- sidebyside preview is used now, feels very good, a lot better than the pip 22:53 -- the speakers swith, cuts are not perfect but feel actually very smooth 22:56 -- composition mode switches again to the sidebyside preview but the speaker is moving a little more so the camera has to pan, does that very smooth and minimizes the needed panning quite well 22:58 -- speakers swith again to the first one, quite well done 22:59 -- again sidebyside preview, feels best suited for this talk for me too 23:01 -- speaker makes almost no movement, camera and composition feel optimal 23:02 -- speaker swith again to the second one 23:04 -- sidebyside preview is used again, feels a little bit late, size of the text on the slides would have allowed that much earlier 23:05 -- speaker walks back to the desk, camera does not compensate the tilt, so the speaker runs out of headspace for a short time 23:06 -- speaker switches again to the first one 23:07 -- very clean cut to the audience applausing, no faces here 23:07 -- hearold enters the stage and asks for q/a - none there 23:08 -- people start to stand up, faces not directly visible, but some people might be identifiable from the side 23:08 -- break occures ------- Practical Mix Network Design David Stainton, jeffburdges ------- 23:28 the Herold starts the introduction 23:30 the speakers starts 23:31 pip overlay some text of the slied 23:35 one speaker cut in half 23:38 someone run in to the camera picture 23:42 side by side, fells good 23:43 some half behind heads 23:56 many behind heads 00:01 Speaker runs out of the camera(in crop) 00:07 q /a side by side one camera shows the Herold and one the two speaker. 00:12 one arm from a speaker cut 00:15 q/a ends 00:15 no Stream screen