Please log in this format (please don't change this example just copy and paste it]: -------- [title of the talk] //see schedule in the other tab [nick of the observer angle] -------- [timestamp system time hh:mm] herald introduces the speaker and talk [timestamp system time hh:mm] speaker starts the talk [timestamp system time hh:mm] [$Suggestion for Improvement] ... [timestamp system time hh:mm] talk ends --> [Conclusion here] _____________________________________________________ ---- Methodisch inkorrekt! _Lucy_ ---- 11:30 Start 11:30 Please don't use Cam 3, theres too much audience in the picture, there is no audio, talk hasn't started yet, maybe you want that 11:33 Herald on Stage 11:40 Wöhrl walks out of frame while speaking 11:40 short video blackouts 11:41 the close-up is not so good because they change the one who speaks high frequently, the cam 3 is also not so good, it's great if you show them both near but complete 11:49 showing slide too long 11:51 music is a bit too loud to hear the speaker well 11:53 too much audience in frame 11:56 showing gif for too long fullscreen 11:57 both speakers are just half in frame on the far ends 11:59 short video blackout 12:02 the camera in the Back shows too much audience 12:08 if just one speaks and they're on the far ends of the stage, go earlier on the closeUp of the speaker, as you did some seconds later 12:14 it's irritating when you can see so much of the beamer in a CloseUp 12:14 audio is away for some seconds 12:16 show a picture slide a little longer 12:17 ?Is it good to show the audience from the front if the speaker walks in the audience? normally c3 doesn't want to show people unasked on video/pictures 12:34 speaker walks out of frame, change to closeup a bit late 12:45 Focus of SteadyCam was not good 12:49 the Compressor-sound was too loud 13:07 Don't show the screen if there are the faces of the audience visible 13:09 side by side is shown for too long, slide is not so interesting 13:15 slide on full screen is better, because the text is so small 13:17 speaker walks out of frame 13:18 good that you changed away from pic in pic 13:19 slide is not interesting enough for side by side 13:19 but good for the video 13:22 the slide was easy readable before, you don't need to show it fullscreen 13:24 short video blackout 13:26 Proposal :D 13:28 Herald on Stage 13:29 End of talk It would be more beautiful if you couldn't see the SteadyCam so often, but thats okay. -------- Regulating Autonomous Weapons -------- 13:51 Folienansicht nicht zu lange halten, Splitbildschirm kürzer halten 13:53 Rednerin größer halten / Näher ran zoomen und headroom kleiner halten. 13:57 Im Bild-im-Bild-Modus die Rednerin ebenfalls größer im Bild halten 14: 00 Kamera rechtzeitig auf Herald schalten -------- Antipatterns und Missverständnisse in der Softwareentwicklung -------- 14:31 Mezzomix aus dem Bild raus halten -> Schleichwerbung 14:34 Gerne mal zwischen Pic-in-Pic und Side-by-side abwechseln bei den Slides 14:43 bei Fefe kann man nicht viel falsch machen mit dieser Perspektive, man kennt die Slides selten im voraus. 14:50 hin und wieder eilt der Ton dem Bild voraus - wenige Millisekunden nur, aber bei genauerem Hinsehen durchaus leicht erkennbar 15:00 Ab und zu ist für eine halbe Sekunde das Bild einer der Kameras weg (Fehler sollte bekannt sein) 15:04 Talk zu Ende -------- Vintage Computing for Trusted Radiation Measurements and a World VBen -------- 15:20 Talk stated delayed with herald on stage 15:20 wrong pciture of both spekaers one of them almost cut 15:23 Speaker would be nice to see while talking about the picture 15:24 This view works better 15:24 speaker sometimes stands on a dar spot on stage or the iris of the camera is not set corretly 15:27 good to stay on map slide while the speaker displays extra content 15:29 good to show the speaker in full screen while he is prenseting the "plutonium" 15:29 wrong cutover to the wrong speaker who is not speaking 15:30 to fast switch betwen sbs preview and fullscreen of slides 15:30 picture in picture would be better since ther is no content on the lower right corner of the slides 15:34 switch to sbs preview is too laste 15:35 perhaps the SBS preview is a good idea to use for this talk, because the fontsize in most lides is big enough 15:37 i'm missing the speaker 15:38 good to switch to sbs preview 15:38 sadly switched back to fullscreen slides 15:39 picture in picture works good here 15:39 fast switch back to full screen slides 15:44 good to show the speaker in picture in picture mode for the heder slides 15:48 a better closeup of the Demo would be nice 15:54 good to stay on the explanation foil and display the speaker when possible in PIP mode 15:59 the sbs equal is a good selection here 16:02 good view of both speakers 16:06 some compression issues on the die picture before the colosing foil 16:07 don't use the overview cam so long 16:08 good tracking of the speaker while answering 16:08 wrong zoom factor at first, both speakers are cut off 16:09 herald not visible while moderating, but this is tot an issue here 16:11 goot switch to wider angle 16:12 good tracking of the speaker closeup 16:14 talk end 16:15 infobeamer was on strem but still some audio from the herald --> the tals was good understanbale, the including of the apple 2 video into the stream was perfect. It would be extreamly hard to make a better recording of the talk. -------- Cryptocurrencies, smart contracts, etc.: revolutionary tech? Eike -------- 16:28 Herald starts talk 16:29 Talk starts 16:34 speaker is shown to small 16:34 picture a bit to dark somethimes 16:43 camera picture is blurred 16:55 camera picture sharp, maybe switch to a closer view of the lecturer. 17:05 soind cuts for a second 17:11 Q n A starts 17:35 shift ends talk continues 17:35 everything allright till now. 17:37 talk ends -------- Protecting Your Privacy at the Border Kuma -------- [18:30] herald starts [18:30] no picture of Herald? [18:33] maybe too much audience [18:33] talk starts [18:35] supersource better then PiP [18:36] speaker sometimes out of frame, maybe zoom out a bit (get 34c3-logo in frame , first line) [18:39] speaker not completely in frame [18:42] nice setup [18:48] good supersource pic, (whole 34c4 visible) as well as moving with the speaker [18:52] side of speaker cut of [18:55] please show slides as soon as possible [18:59] whole be nic to show new speaker sooner [19:00] first speaker partly in frame; maybe abit more headroom on speaker 2 [19:02] nice setup with supersource, but some parts of speaker partly out of frame [19:06] elbo of speaker 1 sometimes in frame [19:12] rigth hand of current speaker often out of frame, maybe zoom out a little [19:15] slide a little bit too short? [19:17] could have stayed a bit longer in fullscreen [19:21] start of q and a [19:22] too much audience [19:22] good frame with both speakers [19:24] too much audience [19:26] person going through frame [19:28] head of Herald not completely in frame [19:29] far away-cam not good choice [19:30] not the talking speaker in frame [19:31] maybe to soon to infobeamer? [19:31] end of talk -------- Are all BSDs createed equally? kuma -------- [19:41] Herald starts [19:44] Talk starts [19:45] nicht introduction of PiP, cpould have been earlier [19:46] Nice fame of speaker for PiP [19:47] fast reaktion for change in slide [19:50] part of screen in picture: maybe zoom in or pan to the right [19:51] would be nice if cam-pic had either none or whole first line of 34v3 logo [19:53] black screen?, maye earlier to side-by-side [19:54] demo to small, --fixed [20:02] cound have siwtched PiP off sooner [20:08] part of the text on the slide is covered by PiP, could have changed sooner [20:13] why no more PiP? [20:16] text on slide too small for side-by-side, use PiP! [20:21] like the frame of speake cam [20:28] what was the point of the total stage cam? [20:35] start of QaA [20:42] stopped stream in the middle of the heralds sentence [20:43] end of talk -------- Tiger, Drucker und ein Mahnmal dbenzhuser -------- 21:01 Stream starts, Herold on stage 21:03 Herold introduces speakers 21:05 Talk starts 21:05 Camera slightly shaky at the beginning 21:08 Fullscreen on slides good during the animations 21:09 Side by side preview could also work to show speakers 21:11 good framing on the speakers 21:11 Side by side preview works well 21:14 Full screen good choice on slides with a lot of text 21:21 Speakers could be shown after video 21:25 Fullscreen works well as there are a lot of videos with sound 21:29 Fullscreen good during slides with small text 21:31 Chance to show speakers (ex. side by side preview) 21:32 Switch to side by side preview was made 21:37 Very good timing when switching at end and start of videos 21:46 Short audio-only part in video (stream black) 21:49 Switch to side by side preview a little late (slides containing only big images) 21:52 Text probably not readable on low-rez streams (but I don't think fullscreen would help) 22:01 Speakers could be shown, as all relevant text was read by them 22:03 Audience visible in wide shot 22:03 ... and through hand held(?) camera (not clear why this low angle was used here) 22:05 Talk stopped. Not clear whether stream is supposed to continue. 22:05 Stream stopped Very calm editing overall. I would have preferred to to have the speakers faces visible a bit more (their faces being sort of part of the performance). -------- Decoding Contactless (Card) Payments Birger -------- 22:18 Start 22:20 Speaker moves a lot. Camera follows. Instead of following the speaker, perhaps it would be better to keep him in a larger static frame. 22:20 Sound issues. Volume changes a few times. 22:23 Audio gone for about 10s. 22:24 Jump from slides to Side-by-Side-Preview (SbSP), not sure if that should be done. 22:27 Why remove the PiP? There was nothing interesting behind the small picture. 22:29 Speaker often has hands straight down and they are cut off. Camera should zoom out to include hands. 22:30 Very minor static spike in audio. 22:31 Again, a spike. 22:31 Perhaps a SbSP would be helpful? Font may be too small though. Speaker may move too much to put him into a nice view in SbSP. 22:34 Camera on speaker should either be zoomed in or out. 22:41 Not sure if this one slide needs to be shown that long. 22:55 Has there been a lag between video and audio for all the time? 22:58 Answering the first question, the speaker speaks to person in audience to the left, should the speaker be put to the right of the frame? The same applies to the herald. 23:05 You should probably not follow the speaker or herald and instead give them more space in the frame. 23:09 Camera blinks for a few ms. This has happened a few times during the talk. 23:16 Heads visible. 23:16 End -------- This is NOT a proposal about mass surveillance! Birger -------- Audio is in sync is much better now but still not perfect. 23:30 Start 23:31 You should not follow the herald so much. 23:32 Camera was out of focus and fixed straight away. 23:33 Audio dead for about 5 seconds. 23:35 Font in slides may be to small for Side-by-Side Preview (SbSP) in lower quality streams. They are OK in HD. The slides contain text in lower right corner which may prevent usefull usage of Picture-in-Picture (PiP). The static position of the speaker allows for nice uses of SbSP. 23:42 Volume of the speaker was reduced. Not sure why. This may have been a local thing on the observing machine. 23:43 Camera still seems to be out of focus. The speaker's desk is in focus, the speaker herself is not. 23:49 Interesting total view of the speaker for a change... 23:51 ... however, this view should probably not be used that often as it does not add more information. The speaker is likely to small for lower resulution streams and essentially has the same size as in SbSP. We only see more of her static sourrounding. 00:00 Should the slides still be shown while the speaker reads a text which is not on the slides? 00:08 23: End ------- Nougatbytes ------- 00:57 Zoomed out camera is slightly overexposed 00:59 Clearly visible person from the audience visible for a short time. Probably also do somthing about the audience heads in case someone turns around 01:00 slide visible only very late 01:03 short glitch, black image for a fraction of a second? 01:05 person on the image border 01:08 could be zoomed in a bit in order to exclude the arm in the lower left corner 01:08 another small black glitch in the video 01:09 forehead cut off 01:13 slide visible very long while people are laughing and joking which would have been more interesting to show instead 01:14 person on the left almost cut off (shot of the right couch) 01:15 same thing on the left couch now, moderator cut in half 01:18 still the arm in the corner, could be zoomed in slightly more Moderater still cut in half 01:21 PIP of two camera shots 01:23 another black glitch but only the camera shot which was in the PIP frame, slides displayed normally 01:24 prefer showing the laughing people after the solution was uncovered instead of showing the slide for a long time 01:26 another black glitch, only camera image problematic again 01:32 moderator still cut off in the shot of the left sofa 01:33 rapid cut succession 01:33 another black glitch 01:34 another rapid cut 01:41 another black glitch 01:45 wild cuts 01:53 the "VR" answer was very quiet 01:54 moderator cut in half (camera showing left sofa) 01:56 the shot of the right sofa is pretty much perfect 01:59 Answer "Secure boot" was barely audible 02:02 black glitch in camera stream 02:03 camera pan was visible, moderator cut in half again when it stopped. 02:04 another black glitch in camera stream 02:09 one of the people on the couch seems to have his mic only amplified but not recorded 02:10 another black glitch 02:15 and another one 02:19 hum in the audio, especially noticable if it's quiet might have been there for longer already 02:25 cut person on the right (moderator shot) 02:28 answer "hidden service" was barely audible 02:37 camera zooming and panning around is shown, shaky end 02:38 end