Server Notice:

hide

Public Pad Latest text of pad streamObserver34C3-Tag2-HallD Saved Dec 29, 2017

Please log in the folowing format:

--------

[Title of the talk] // see next tab 2.pdf or Fahrplan (app)

[your nick in the Engelsystem]

--------

[Digitale Bildung in der Schule]

[Ho Chi]

--------

[1:48:45] Switch to fullscreen slides if there's code

[1:50:00] Gutes Timing

[1:55:10] Vollbild wäre früher besser gewesen.

[1:58:00] Mehr Vollbild auf Slides bei Code

[1:59:00] Fullscreen bei Code, mehr. Die Speakerin macht ja relativ wenig Gesten

[2:01:00] Don't use this side by side mode most of the time. You can see the code cleaner, if its fullscreen.

[2:11:00] Good mixing

--------

28.12.2017

[Visceral Systems / presented by Sarah Grant]

[Stormwind]

--------

[17:00] a bit long fullscreen on a simple slide

[18:00] stayed a long time on slides

[19:45] long time on simple slide > 1 min

[20:45] better: sbs eq

[21:45] long time on slide

[22:50] good timing

[24:00] long time on slide backt o speaker until the next slide at 24:50

[25:40] would have liked to see what shes pointing at, happens at 26:10

[27:00] still on sbsprev, would have gone back to speaker

[27:45] long time on fullscreen picture

[28:45] pip instead of back to speaker

[29:15] pip looks good here

[29:30] now fullscreen slides for better detail on the pictures

[31:00] long time on photo slide

[31:30] long time on simple slide

[33:00] way too long on slide with just two big lines

[33:30] sbs prev good camera angle and magnification

[34:50] speaker moves out of frame

[36:30] spsprev for 1.5 min without transition spseq might habe been better, with going back to the speaker

[37:50] late switch to pip, pcture not that interesting

[40:00] staying on the speaker for wrapup was okay

[40:20] no contact slides instead of showing the herald

[40:40] nice angle with herals and speaker

[40:50] maybe switch to speaker for the answer

[41:50] herald stands still while speaker answers, looks not soo good for the herals

[42:50] speaker fullscreen while she is looking for a video not so interesting. Maybe there was no better angle for the moment

[44:05] back to the herald instead of both

[44:25] late switch to fullscreen slide/video

[45:15] late switch to stage

[45:40] well timed switch to speaker for answer, maybe a second late

[46:20] speaker walks almost out of the frame, cam following would have been nice if smoothly possible

-------

[Making Experts Makers and Makers Experts / by Daniel Wessolek, Isabelle Dechamps]

[Stormwind]

-------

[1:01:10] good placement and timing of title slide

[1:01:20] left speaker cropped

[1:02:00] picture frame a bit too far on the right, left speaker is cropped out from time to time

[1:03:50] would like to have seen female speaker when she begins speaking

[1:04:30] sbsprev looks good here, good framing

[1:05:00] speaker leaves the frame for a short time

[1:06:00] full screen slide would have been nice

[1:06:30] good angle on both speakers, maybe a bit more zoomed in might have been better

[1:11:30] second camera further zoomed in on speakers would have been better

[1:12:00] good transition to slides

[1:13:20] pip might have worked here better

[1:14:00] staying for slides worked well for the transistions the speakers did

[1:15:30] longish time on slide, switch to speaker would have been nice

[1:15:50] small stutter between cams

[1:16:40] bit too long on fullscreen slides

[1:17:00] good angle on both speakers now

[1:17:20] too long on slides fullscreen

[1:18:29] slides flickering into black - origin in video chain or slides on presenter's pc?

[1:19:00] cam on male speaker on handover would have been nice before returning to fullscreen slides

[1:20:20] closeup un male speaker showing the hardware would have been nice

[1:20:50] like that, but speaker's head is cropped off

[1:22:00] slides flicker black

[1:22:15] difficult camera angle with boths speakers

[1:22:30] sbsprev with camera following speaker on it's own would have been nice

[1:23:10] angle on both works well, maybe a bit too centered

[1:24:45] picture frame too far to the left

[1:25:45] well timed transition pip would have worked better here with free space on the shown website

[1:26:10] black flicker

[1:27:10] cam follow female speaker, moves out of frame to the left

[1:28:00] a bit too long on fullscreen slide

[1:28:10] camera too far right, corrected around 1:28:20, still a bit too far to the right

[1:29:50] a bit zoomed out too much on herald

[1:30:10] good camera angle

[1:32:50] good transition to herald, hasty stream cutoff

-------

[Think big or care for yourself]

[AKO, Hanna Wülle]

-------

[13:46:00] Half second speaker

[13:01:30] unbalance camera view, she is to right

[14:03:00] now make the same camera view more sence.

[14:05:00] the hand outside of the camera

[14:11] Camera was not ready for herald, herald move out of the camera, and after a strong camera move

[14:17] viberation on the camera,the camera shoud wait until the mixer say it finished

-------

[May contain DTraces of]

[raichoo]

-------

[14:37] good camera view for his hand and body move

[14:48] slide have a small font, difficult to read with small screen like my as stream observer, but the mixer cant make it better

[14:46] in this view, it impossible to read the comand on my screen

[14:57] cant read anything this 12 inch screen.

--------

[Netzpolitik in der Schweiz]

[15:17] nice to see the speaker as well, as the slide for overview

[15:20] speaker hard to see in picture in picture and wide angle view

[15:25] closer view on speaker recomended in picture in picture

[15:27] nice to see speaker in fullscreen

[15:31] side by side views may be more interesting

[15:44] slide doesn't show intresting content

[15:51] can't see the speaker, too small

[15:55] Transition nice between Sentences of speaker

[15:59] audience in view

[15:59] nice view to speakers

[16:00] rather show speakers while questions not herald

------

[Free electron lasers]

[16:36] nice to see the animation speaker talked about

[16:37] side by side view nicely fitting

[16:41] show the speaker in side by side prev. or eq.

[16:50] nice fullscreen while ?applaus?

[17:13] the side by side view still nice!, but cam could move a little less

[17:29] all in all quite a nice stream, thanks :-)

--------

[How to drift with any car]

[Vben]

[18:30] Starts with herold

[18:30] nervous camera movements at start

[18:31] bad lighting for second speaker (Bad left of speakers desk)

[18:32] Side by side preview is nice here

[18:33] Speaker sometimes out of side by side but good view

[18:35] good to show the slides again

[18:35] Speaker sometimes out of camera in sbs

[18:38] The speaker picure covers some minor infos on the slide

[18:39] good view with the speaker and slides epspecially with tzhe animation and videos

[18:47] A closeup of the laughing speaker would be nice

[18:48] Good closeup and camera following of the speaker

[18:50] Good to view the video without the speaker

[18:52] the handover between the speakers in fullscreen would be better

[18:54] pip works better with this slide but the speaker in fullscreen is also good

[18:55] switch over to see the slide too late

[18:59] speaker steps out of sbs preview window

[19:00] speaker would be nice in picture in picture mode because ther is no information lost

[19:01] readjusting the focus while live is not a good idea

[19:02] nervous camera following because the speaker is moving in sbs preview

[19:04] good to go in fullscreen with this chip slide

[19:07] good to show both speakers together

not a good ider to have a backback on the speakers desk

[19:09] good to view the closing slide

[19:09] herald sarts Q&A

[19:10] one audicence head appears

[19:10] camera should keep both speakers in picture and not cut one of them

[19:13] herald not shown while moderating the next question

[19:16] fast camera reaction on moving speaker

[19:20] Talk ended perfact to show the closing slide at the end

Conclusion: I enjoyed wathing the stream, it would be really hard to make ist better than that

-----

Humnas as software

-fabi-, birger

-----

19.48 speaker (stream oberserving starts)

No use of PiP Super Source. Instead, only Side-by-Side Super Source. This way the speaker is too small most of the time.

20:04:40 Poor audio at the start of the video

20:08:35 White projector screen does not contain any information and should not be shown.

20:11 Herald seems to start to talk before going onto the stage. Herald not shown during closing of the talk.

20:11 05 Camera shaking

20:35 stand in Stream observer

20:38 maybe show the speaker bigger no need seeing all the desk

-----

Afro TECH

birger

-----

General remarks on this talk:

- Use picture-in-picture when possible instead of side-by-side.

- Watch out for head-space.

- Try to get the speaker closer if posible.

20:41 The view is too wide and could be closer to the speaker.

-----

The Noise Protocol

sedrubal

-----

21:14 - hard start with stage manager announcements

21:15 - speaker starts speaking, camera is following perfectly

21:16 - Slides have black bars on left and right side, they are 4:3, video is 16:9!!!

21:17 - camera has too much headroom but cuts off gestures below

21:17 - mixer mixes well

21:18 - 4:3 slides in 16:9 stream look bad in side by side view

21:19 - camera is a bit waving all the time

21:20 - side by side equal (?) with slides looks baaad! speaker is too large and slides are too small. Don't use it!

21:21 - stream observer laptops are shitty

21:23 - camera is zoomed out too far

21:25 - side by side equal is imho not useful

21:27 - "secure channel protocols" slide contains quite small text -> side by side might not be the correct choice

21:30 - slide "noise framework concept" is cutted off on the right slide (speakers fail)

21:30 - camera is still zoomed out too far

21:32 - gestures of speaker were clipped

21:34 - slide "noise framework overview" contains small text -> side by side might not be the correct choice

21:38 - speaker camera flickered (and jumped?)

21:38 - side by side equal is imho quite unusable. Why does the speaker need so a large picture? It's not a hardware live demo

21:43 - Speaker finished talk

21:43 - Herold is not visible / hearable, Q&A suddenly starts

21:45 - camera is still zoomed out too far

21:45 - Question micro (1?) is a bit quiet

21:46 - Q&A ended by speaker(!?!?) and mixer starts pause video perfectly

------

Implementing an LLVM based Dynamic Binary Instrumentation framework

sedrubal

------

22:00 - still pause video

22:01 - stream starts in the middle of introduction

22:01 - applause sound changes when enabling speaker mic

22:02 - slides are 4:3 again

22:06 - slide "why not ... debuggers" contain light green text on white background (speakers fail)

22:07 - pip overlaps relevant parts of video

22:10 - speaker walks out of picture in side by side preview

22:10 - headroom is ok

22:10 - luminosity **too dark** (maybe the apperture is wrong?)

22:10 - I think the camera image is not sharp, too

22:12 - there is small text on slide "no free space" -> side by side preview might not be the correct setup

22:14 - camera can/should zoom a bit out, as the speaker is moving much

22:14 - second speaker sound is too quiet, you only hear the echo

22:15 - sound of second speaker was muted for some seconds

22:15 - sound gets better

22:15 - no sound of speaker 2 for 10 seconds

22:21 - camera is waving

22:22 - speaker sound was muted for 10 seconds

22:25 - speaker is quite vivd, but cameras are following quite well

22:29 - luminosity is better now or this is the other camera? If so, mixer should check that luminosity is equal on both cameras before talk starts

22:31 - speaker change worked quite smoothly

22:33 - camer image was shaking (someone jumped on camera platform)

22:34 - (mixer could switch to slides in fullscreen, because camera image is not really worth to show it and text on slides is quite small)

22:38 - (headroom is a bit large)

22:43 - speaker change -> head of speaker 2 is cut off

22:47 - live demo: speaker can't type in front of audience ;)

22:55 - showing live demo in fullscreen is correct choice

22:59 - Q&A starts

22:59 - Show speakers during Q&A answers

23:00 - why are there 2 heralds?

23:00 - pause video starts just at the perfect moment

------

Growing Up Software

dbenzhuser

------

23:15 Stream starts Herold already speaking

23:16 Speaker starts

23:17 First slides with pictures and text in it, shown long enough

23:18 Cut to PiP a bit too late in first actual text slide (enough space on lower right), when switch happened, speaker changed the slide immediately ;)

23:21 Switch to side by side preview was right, but a little late

23:22 Framing of speaker with slighly cut of hands as he moved between the lower desk and his laptop (slightly wider or do not follow when he reaches to change slides)

23:24 Good follow as the speaker walks further onto the stage

23:25 Side by side preview a good choice for his type of slides and speaker movement

23:25 Fullscreen was moving slightly too much

23:27 Fullscreen on slide with small code - good, but futile

23:27 Speaker has zoomed in versions of the code, very usefull

23:30 Tight framing of speaker in side by side preview means camera has to be a bit restless (I don't know whether wider framing would help or make the speaker too small)

23:36 Camera movement could be smoother (slower pan, react faster)

23:38 Speaker keeps to fool the camera by making fake moovements towards his laptop

23:40 slides have small, but irrelevant text. Good choice not to switch for fullscreen

23:42 Talk is over

23:43 Herald nearly invisible in front of dark curtain

23:43 Speaker could have been shown earlier during the first question from the audience.

23:45 Good calm framing during questions. Camera did not minimize the space behind the speaker, but he kept looking left and right anyways

23:46 Camera was shaking a split second before the stream stopped. Camera operator should wait to move until stream is stopped.

23:46 Stream stopped

General positive remark: The mixer learned quickly, that there was no need to go on fullscreen for small text - small text was either irrelevant or zoomed in on next slide.

------

Robot Music

dbenzhuser

------

23:59 Stream starts, Herald already talking

00:00 Audio issues anounced, stream paused again

00:01 Stream is back

00:02 Speakers not shown during their introduction

00:03 Left speaker out of focus

00:03 Camera shaking slightly

00:04 Having both speakers in wide shot would be better, as left speaker looks out of frame

00:05 Quick switch to side by side preview when slide changes, but camera had short trouble having the current speaker in frame