It looks like you're having connection troubles. Reconnect now.
12/30/2017 00:34:01
Public Pad Latest text of pad streamObserver34C3-Tag3-HallC Saved Dec 30, 2017 |
Please log in this format (please don't change this example just copy and paste it]:
--------
[title of the talk] //see schedule in the other tab
[nick of the observer angle]
--------
[timestamp system time hh:mm] herald introduces the speaker and talk
[timestamp system time hh:mm] speaker starts the talk
[timestamp system time hh:mm] [$Suggestion for Improvement]
...
[timestamp system time hh:mm] talk ends
--> [Conclusion here]
_____________________________________________________
--------
Taxation
-fabi-
--------
11.28 - herald introduces the speaker and talk
11.29 - info screens
11.30 - pause screen and sound
11.33 - herold introduces
11.33 - speaker starts the talk
11.29 - Placing desk im "goldenen Schnitt"
11.33 - mix: be online on time - herold not complete
11.34 - cam: frame speaker little bit more to the right
11.35 - cam: better framed
11.35 - cam: nice framed, for my opinion a little bit too wide
11.36 - mix: perfectly mixed and cut to the slides
11.39 - logo in the upper right corner shades slide content
11.43 - cam: bit narrower and a tiny little bit less head room
11.45 - mix: nice forelooking mixing
11.47 - mix: fine and small font being used in slide. full screen slides would be better
11.49 - mix: very small fonts - slides should really bull full screen
12.00 - recipients are in the framing when leaving the room
12.00 - cam: herold is cut in half on the left side
12.01 - cam: nice framing, but unsharp image
12.01 - head in the far lower right corner
12.02 - cam: framing little bit more nose room on the left would be great
12.05 -ttalk ends
--> [Conclusion here]
* Nice mixing job
* slides with thin/small fonts should be shown in full screen
* No Logo when slides are shown (or at least the possibility to let logo
vanish or allow to be rearranged)
_____________________________________________________
--------
Bringing Linux back to server boot ROMs with NERF and Heads
-fabi-
--------
before: screen is being streamed some time
12.15 - herald introduces the speaker and talk (no direct audio at first)
12.16 - speaker starts the talk
12.18 - cam: seems to shake a bit
12.19 - cam: Has gain changed suddenly? Exopsure settings seems not to be good!
12.23 - mix: very small fonts. Not readable. Slides shoudl be full screen
12.25 - mix: very very very small fontss.
Should really really befull screen (fixed, not readable either)
12.31 - mix: Should be shown in full screen,
authors of the shown paper are hard to read
12.35 - cam: Nice framed, could be a tiny little bit more nose room.
exposure not good
12.39 - audio sometimes not properly mixed (not just dry audio from the speaker)
12.41 - cam: very nice framed, although expore not good
12.45 - talk ends
12.45 - next talk slides
12.45 - some noise form an oopen microphone
12.45 - pause slides and sound
-->
* Not streaming screen output before talk has begun
* Check exposure settings
* Possibility to remote control exposure settings, colour temp, ... may be could be corrected by mixing angle or my be a new angle. So the camera angle can focus on framing, field of view and focus. Maybe like to curves tool in Photoshop to adjust hue, brightness, colour ...
_____________________________________________________
--------
Designing PCBs with code
-fabi-
--------
12.59 - herald introduces the speaker and talk (no direct audio from herold!!)
12.59 - audio: some smacking audio noise
13.00 - speaker starts the talk
13.02 - mix: don't understand this super source composition - slides are toooooo small to read anything, speaker is too small
13.03 - mix: fixed by showing full screen slides
13.05 - cam: could be a little but narrower
13.05 - audio: no signal for 1..2 seconds
13.06 - cam: also framing is nice, for my opinion it's too wide for pic in pic
13.16 - cam/mix/stream: interlacing artefact visible when person walks
13.18 - herold audio too late
13.20 - cam: focus right on herald?
13.21 - mix: herald is speaking - video is on speaker
13.22 - talks ends
13.22 - pause slildes and audio
--> [Conclusion here]
* Check camera settings right before to ensure they are equally set
(exoosure, colour, ...)
* At 13.06 with pic in pic, there is just imoportant information in the right end of the camera picture. maybe it#s possible to cut out the left empty space. One could see more of the slides without loosing any important details of the camera image.
_____________________________________________________
-------
History and implications of DRM
[usr16549]
-------
13:40 - herald viewable
13:44 - introduction of talk topic
13:45 - speaker introduction
13:45 - talk starts
13:45 - shaky camera. speaker out of frame on time. headspace slightly too large
13:46 - good camera tracking
13:47 - camera tracking of speaker still a bit shaky
13:48 - due to high speaker movement, might consider swithing to slide-fullscreen
- on the other hand, due to very limited content on the slides, might consider full screen speaker (wider aspect)?
13:52 - speaker walks partly out of frame. see point above
13:54 - might consider reducing headspace
13:56 - might consider swithing to slide full-screen
13:57 - speakers' arms are clipped
13:57 - still no switch
13:58 - strange switching of camera (same cam setting)
14:01 - headspace is much improved
14:04 - finally switched
14:07 - switching to speaker would make significantly more sense
14:09 - talk ends
- switch to full-screen
- switch to herald, but speaker speaking (to be fair, speaker intervenes in heralds speaking)
- speaker halfway in frame
14:10 - herald partly in frame, might consider zooming into speaker
14:12 - good camera tracking
14:13 - audio problems
- heralds head cut off
- herald partly in frame
- heralds head cut off
14:15 - might want to zoom into speaker, as herald keeps walking into frame
- then again, speaker has quite the expressive hand gestures
14:16 - good camera switch
14:17 - end of Q&A
14:18 - stream paused
- slighly quick to pause, as speaker was cut off mid sentence
------
Net neutrality enforcement in the EU
[usr16549]
------
* the speaker does seem to have quite the preference for side-by-side preview
14:26 - herald visible
14:27 - speaker/talk introduction
14:28 - talk starts
14.28 - speaker audio muffled
14:29 - side-by-side preview with a camera which is not zoomed in enough (applies to the whole talk)
13:30 - either the camera should be zoomed onto the face of the speaker, or the slides should be visible full-screen
14:31 - same as 14:29
14:32 - good switch; speaker points to slide -> side-by-side
14:33 - might want to zoom into frame and adjust camera angle, as there is quite some headspace
14:35 - might want to switch to slides, as some of the text is reasonably small
14:37 - strange switching
14:38 - still no switch to full slides. the speaker does not add to the audiences experience at this stage
14:42 - black background is having blocking artefacts (might be the laptop)
14:43 - switch to speaker seems unnecessary
14:46 - the headspace critique still applies
14:52 - good switch to full slides
14:55 - good switch to full slides
14:57 - talk ends
14:58 - switch to herald, then to speaker; speaker walks out of frame. [camera coordination?]
- headspace in new shot significantly improved.
14:59 - end of Q&A
15:00 - stream paused
- it might have been better to pause slightly earlier, as the herald was cut of mid sentence [not relevant to the talk, though]
______________________________________________
--------
Open Source Estrogen
[Candoshi]
--------
15:15 Herald visible
15:16 Herald introduces topic
15:17 Talk begins
15:18 slides only view => good
15:22 side by side preview => all fine
15:25 good switch from side by side to speaker only and then slides only
15:27 maybe to much switching between full speaker view, side by side or slides
=> side by side and full slides would be enough?
15:31 good switch to full slides because of small text
15:35 bad, small text on slide and not switched to fullscreen slides
15:44 sometimes to short time on full slide view
15:47 talk end
15:47 Herald comes then Q&A
15:47 Q&A sound good
16:13 Q&A end
16:13 Stream paused
--> Conclusion
SOUND: all fine
VIDEO: good switching, good light/exposure setting, sometimes to short on slides
_____________________________________________________
--------
UPSat - The first open source satellite
Michos
--------
[16:30] herald introduces the speaker and talk
[16:31] speaker starts the talk
[16:31] nice switch between herald and speaker
[16:31] short audio drop-out
[16:35] nit: the two small white blips from the Phasenprüfer at the bottom are a bit disturbing, zooming in a tiny bit would have been nice
[16:58] Talks ends, Q&A starts, Hall Mic 1 was opened a bit late
-->
really nice framing in side-by-side preview, really nice switching between slides, speaker and side-by-side
overall, super well done!
Stream probably should have been paused between the two talks and defragmentation
_____________________________________________________
--------
SatNOGS - Crowd sourced satellite operations
Michos
--------
[17:06] herald introduces the speaker and talk
[17:07] speaker starts the talk
[17:21] In room-view, too many heads, slides cut off at the top (from Cam 3 or whatever the fixed one is in Borg ;-)
[17:28] talk ends & Q&A starts
[17:34] Q&A ends
-->
Same as previous talk (same mixer & cam?), really well done. Nice cuts and framing
_____________________________________________________
--------
Running GSM Mobile Phone on SDR
Yao "Meow" Wei
--------
20:59 Herald introduces the speakers and the talk
21:00 Speakers start the talk
21:02 The slides seems have many texts, and sometimes small: Could use full-frame on slides often then side-by-side preview afterwards before new content coming up.
21:04 Stream pauses for buffering (computer problem?)
21:08 Slides show a diagram which is probably better using full-frame.
21:11 The text on the slides is probably too small for streaming audience with smaller video.
21:12 The diagram is shown full-screen.
21:14 The screen goes back to side-by-side preview
21:19 Small text and diagram: better use full-frame on slides.
21:21 The slides have broken text...
21:25 A man walks by the podium...
21:25 The diagram is really small... full-frame is better in that situation.
21:25 Speakers are doing live demo with terminal. Full-frame is used though the text is still small in full-frame.
21:30 The speakers start the Q&A section.
21:30 Herald ends the Q&A section due to lack of time.
21:30 Talk ends. Stream pauses.
--> The slides has many small texts and diagrams. Better use full-frame and picture-in-picture when the bottom-right of the slide is empty.
_____________________________________________________
--------
Electroedibles -> Electrolickables
Yao "Meow" Wei
--------
21:46 Herald introduces the speakers (candymakers!) and the talk
21:47 The speakers start the talk. They changed the topic of the talk.
21:49 One of the speakers has little to no sound to the stream.
21:52 Video is shown in the slides. Better use full-frame on the slides.
21:54 Close-up camera is shown in full-frame.
21:56 Close-up cam glitched.
22:00 Close-up cam. The sugar syrup leaked to the top of the IH heater...
22:03 Solder is shown. ...wait is that lead-free!?
22:08 Close-up cam stream glitched.
22:10 The woman speaker walks around. Possibly full-frame on the slides could be better.
22:11 Close-up cam glitched.
22:13 The speaker starts the Q&A session.
22:14 The speaker seems trying to find a slide on the laptop?
22:16 The audiences are shown on the camera for taking candies.
22:16 Talk ends. Stream pauses.
--> Extra care must be taken to use close up cam because the audience can be easily filmed.
--> The close-up cam seems to be not under VOC's control?
--> On a side note of food safety: I am worrying about the solder and lead in this talk.
_____________________________________________________
--------
Extended DNA Analysis
jungfranckianer
--------
22:29 Herald intoduces speaker
22:29 talk starts
22:30 PiP went into slides after the first change. Better to try a few slides on fullscreen
22:30 good to be long in fullscreen as it has a schema
22:31 PiP looks good here, maybe more centered picture of speaker would be good
22:32 next slide was again not good for PiP
22:36 good to stay on the slides as it is not sure, whether this one has more bullet points
22:38 short break of audio !!
22:49 good descision for PiP at the end of the slide
22:51 long time of slides, but this is due to the nature of lecture
22:53 herald opens Q&A
23:00 finish and total view with some heads in.
Conclusion: This talk featured slides with much text/schematics, which build up dynamically. PiP seems like a good concept to cope with that as the slide's content is as large as possible, but the speaker can be seen from time to time. The mixing had sometimes the problem that PiP was used from the beginning of the slide and then the speaker
--------
Es sind die kleinen Dinge im Leben II
jungfranckianer
--------
23:15 herald starts
23:16 Totale showed some heads.
23:17 talk starts
23:17 slides on fullscreen
23:18 preview mode, still okay, speaker is captured okayish, as he moves not to much.
23:20 good for fullscreen
23:23 speaker talks a lot, so fullscreen is good.
23:25 Preview mode is good, as it shows the speakers motivation and slides
23:31 good switch on new slide
23:35 Side-by-Side adds no value IMO
23:36 slides not shown
23:42 last slide could be there a little bit longer
23:43 short fail when only speakers pult was shown
23:43 herald starts Q&A
23:46 finish
Conclusion: This talk featured some pictures on the slides, which where interesting but also a quite motivated speaker with some facial expressions, which made it valuable to show. The preview/super-source mode was used often mostly as a good way of composition. The camera did a good job on holding onto the speaker, so he was not cropped. At the end, some minor slips happened, e.g. using side-by-side with no additional value, one slide, that was not shown, an empty speakers pult when maybe the herald should be captured, which spoiled the otherwise very good performance of mixing.
--------
Public FPGA based DMA Attacking
jungfranckianer
--------
00:01 herald starts, as well as speaker
00:01 start with fullscreen slides, ++
00:06 a lot text on the slides, so good to show it longer
00:07 good switch to speaker closeup here.
00:08 could switch to preview/supersource mode a little bit earlier
00:11 Handy cam could be switched away, but I do not know whether it is under control of mixing angel
00:13 Capturing/cropping of speaker in supersource mode ist good
00:26 herald starts Q&A
00:31 herald finished
Conclusion: The mixing was done well, the preview/supersource is here also a good solution. The cam for the demo was not necessarily in control of the mixer, but worked out well enough.
------------
